Protecting the Preborn

Over the past several years, the debate over how Christians should oppose abortion has shifted.
Since Roe v. Wade was overturned in 2022, many states have pursued complete abortion bans and so-called “heartbeat bills,” which prohibit abortion after six or twelve weeks of gestation. According to a study published in the Journal of the American Medical Association (JAMA), these kinds of laws do have a positive impact for saving the preborn. For example, abortion bans in 14 states resulted in an estimated 22,180 excess births through 2023, a 1.7 increase over the expected total.
That looks like progress—and it indicates that children were saved. Zooming out to a national level, however, reveals a different picture. Data from the Society of Family Planning’s #WeCount project reveals that the average number of abortions performed per month in the U.S. has risen from 77,560 in 2022 to 93,900 in 2025.
While some states restricted abortion, others expanded access. Some women crossed state lines to seek abortions, while many others—more than 300,000 in 2025, according to #WeCount, or approximately 28 percent of abortions nationally—obtained abortions through telehealth services.
Abortion access has changed significantly since the pro-life movement accelerated in the 1980s and 1990s. The abortion industry has adapted to changes in legislation, and in many cases, it is much easier for a woman in the U.S. to abort her baby today than it was two decades ago.
We believe this shift helps explain the emerging divide among those who oppose abortion. Three distinct approaches to defending the rights of the preborn have emerged: abolitionism, smashmouth incrementalism, and the pro-life establishment. Each group wants to “end abortion,” but each has a different strategy for getting there.
Three Streams of Thought in Defending the Preborn
While there are variations within each group, this overview seeks to organize the three strategies according to their common beliefs.
1. Pro-life Establishment
Advocates of this approach seek to reduce and eventually end abortion through education, persuasion (dialogues, debates, campus events, etc.), and the election of pro-life policymakers. Several high-profile organizations lead this movement, with core goals that include:
Pursuing incremental restrictions, such as heartbeat bills, gestational limits, parental consent, and clinical regulations.
Treating women seeking abortions as “second victims” of the abortion industry.
Pursuing the prosecution of abortion doctors.
Opposing criminal penalties against mothers.
Accepting limited exceptions, such as rape, incest, and life of the mother, when political realities require them.
Emphasizing logic, biology, and pragmatism to build broad coalitions.
Major advocates of the pro-life establishment position include National Right to Life (and its
state affiliates), Students for Life of America, Susan B. Anthony Pro-Life America, and the March for Life, along with their allied politicians and lobbyists.
2. Abolitionism
Abolitionism is an emerging minority movement that confronts both the abortion lobby and the pro-life establishment. This group calls for the immediate end of abortion, without delay or qualification, and supports equal protection for the preborn from conception onward. Abolitionists see this as the only biblical way to establish “justice and only justice” for the preborn (Deut. 16:20). While there are significant differences between abolitionist groups and approaches, most hold to these priorities:
Calling for and pursuing immediate, total criminalization of abortion as homicide, with equal protection under existing homicide statutes beginning at fertilization, with no exceptions.
Holding all parties legally accountable, including the mother.
Rejecting every bill that incrementally regulates abortion as an unjust compromise that codifies partiality and delays justice.
Advocates of this position include Virgil Walker, Abolitionists Rising, Foundation to Abolish Abortion, Operation Save America and End Abortion Now, along with their allied politicians and lobbyists.
3. Smashmouth Incrementalism
The third faction shares key principles with both the pro-life establishment and abolitionism, taking a middle ground between them. Like abolitionists, smashmouth incrementalists explicitly seek to end abortion and criminalize those who practice it. But, like the pro-life establishment, they acknowledge that the effort must work within existing political realities. Their core beliefs include:
Working toward the ultimate goal of abolishing all forms of abortion at every stage of pregnancy.
Supporting effective incremental restrictions that save lives now, with the intention of continuing to press for fuller bans and criminalization.
Rejecting abolitionism’s “all-or-nothing” purity tests, which refuse partial gains.
Proponents of this view include pastor Douglas Wilson and philosopher Craig Ireland.
CFBU’s Position
At CFBU, we acknowledge the changing circumstances of abortion access in the U.S. and the need for Christians to reconsider our approach to ending this evil. While we do not align exactly with any of the three streams, we affirm that every human being, from conception, is entitled to equal protection under the law, with no exceptions. We believe this should be the ultimate goal of every effort to change abortion policy.



