Policing

Social justice advocates view policing as a key example of systemic racism, believing that law enforcement disproportionately targets black individuals due to ingrained racial bias within the system. This narrative, amplified by media and cultural voices, shapes public perception and fuels distrust.

Christians are called to evaluate such claims through the lens of Scripture, seeking truth and justice, while also acknowledging human sin and the necessity of societal order. This essay explores the belief that policing embodies systemic racism, counters it with data-driven arguments, and offers a biblical approach to navigating this divisive issue.

The Biblical Foundation for Policing

Scripture affirms that governing authorities, including police, are instituted by God to uphold justice and restrain evil (Romans 13:1-4). Law enforcement and the courts cooperate to bear the “sword” to punish wrongdoers and protect the innocent, aligning with Leviticus 19:15’s call for impartial justice and Psalm 106:3’s blessing on those who uphold it. Policing, when rightly executed, is a divine mechanism to curb sin’s chaos, as seen in Genesis 6:11-13. Yet, as a human institution, it is not immune to corruption. Instances of excessive force or bias reflect the universal reality of human sinfulness (Romans 3:23), necessitating accountability. Christians must affirm policing’s God-ordained role while confronting abuses, guided by a conscience shaped by God’s Word (Romans 2:14-15).

The Claim of Systemic Racism in Policing

Many Americans believe policing is systemically racist, arguing that policies, practices, or cultural norms within law enforcement disproportionately harm black communities. This perspective gained traction following high-profile incidents, with media narratives suggesting officers routinely target black individuals, “hunting them down” in a pattern of racial extermination. Proponents point to disparities in arrests, use of force, and fatal shootings, claiming these reflect a system designed to oppress. For example, black men, comprising about 6% of the population, accounted for roughly 20-25% of police shootings in recent years, which some interpret as evidence of bias. This belief fosters fear, prompting parents to warn their children about police encounters as life-threatening, undermining trust in authority.

Such claims, however, must be tested. Assuming systemic racism without evidence risks perpetuating division and bearing false witness (Exodus 20:16). While historical injustices, like discriminatory practices during the civil rights era, are undeniable, Christians must assess whether these persist systemically today or if alternative factors explain disparities.

Counterarguments Against Systemic Racism

Data-driven analysis challenges the narrative that policing is inherently racist. In 2020, out of an estimated 375 million annual police-citizen interactions, approximately 15 unarmed black men were killed by police, compared to 25 unarmed white men in 2019. Since the 1960s, police killings of black men have declined by 70%, despite a doubled black population, reflecting improved practices driven by policies like Graham v. Connor and Tennessee v. Garner, which established strict standards for use of force. These standards, applied nationwide, require officers to justify force based on the severity of the crime, active resistance, or flight, undermining claims of blanket racial targeting.

Disparities in police interactions often correlate with crime rates rather than race. FBI Uniform Crime Reports indicate that a small percentage of black males (less than 1% of the population) commit over 50% of homicides and 40% of violent crimes annually. Higher crime rates in certain communities naturally lead to increased police presence and interactions, explaining disproportionate outcomes without assuming racism. For instance, in 1972, the NYPD recorded 994 shootings, dropping to 26 by 2019, with only eight fatal, suggesting greater restraint and accountability, not systemic bias.

Moreover, allegations of systemic racism imply collusion across thousands of jurisdictions, yet many agencies with predominantly black leadership, like those in Baltimore or Detroit, have faced similar complaints of excessive force, often under federal oversight. This phenomenon points to human sin—power abuse or cultural heavy-handedness—rather than race-specific policies. Christians must recognize that sin, not skin color, drives misconduct.

Unfortunately, media amplification of police shootings, particularly involving black individuals, perpetuates the systemic racism narrative. Repeated broadcasts create a perception of an epidemic, fostering distrust and fear. This impacts communities, reinforcing beliefs that police are inherently dangerous, and officers, who may feel vilified, leading to reduced proactive policing. Post-2020 protests saw a surge in homicides—estimated at 2,000 more than in 2019—disproportionately affecting black communities, highlighting the unintended consequences of defunding or demonizing police.

A Christian Response

Christians can respond to the policing debate with biblical wisdom. First, pray for officers, who face 58,000 assaults annually, and for communities plagued by crime or distrust. Second, pursue accountability by reporting misconduct legally, ensuring justice without escalating tensions. Third, teach children to comply with police for safety, as an act of prudence, while fostering biblical literacy to discern cultural narratives. Fourth, rather than fueling fear, Christians should encourage respect for authority (1 Peter 2:13-17) while advocating for justice through proper channels, such as reporting abuses to internal affairs, which most agencies investigate rigorously, especially with body cameras and surveillance. Finally, support law enforcement through encouragement and prayer, urging officers to remain rooted in God’s Word to avoid hostility or bias. Local churches can facilitate dialogue between communities and police, promoting reconciliation.

While many Americans believe policing exemplifies systemic racism, data reveals a more complex reality. From a Christian perspective, policing is a God-ordained institution to uphold justice, yet it is marred by human sin, requiring accountability. Christians must reject unverified narratives, seek truth, and foster peace, supporting law enforcement while advocating for righteousness. By grounding our actions in Scripture, we can reflect Christ’s love, bridging divides in a fractured society.

For more on this topic:

• Check out our book, Walking in Unity.

• Watch these videos.